How do you feel about using brown sugar in a shortbread recipe?!
Answers: I know that it's not authentic, but I read some rave reviews of recipes that used brown sugar instead of white. Have you tried this?
I have made many shortbread cookies with brown sugar and find the flavour wonderful. I believe it is the true Scottish recipe.
Take a look at this free ebook with 490 award winning recipes, maybe you can find what you're looking for in it.