Surprised by Questions on this forum?!


Question: I really do try to answer to the best of my knowledge. I don't cut & paste. Mispelled words & poor grammar don't faze me.
Why do some questions post the very same question 4 times and at the same time? Why do student's ask us to do their homework? Why do so many Askers not choose an answer and leave it up to the voters (well I really like the voters because they seem to read all of the answers). Why do those perusing the questions put a thumbs down and often to very good answers. I know I don't ask a lot of questions but I have been thinking a lot about these few things lately.


Answers: I really do try to answer to the best of my knowledge. I don't cut & paste. Mispelled words & poor grammar don't faze me.
Why do some questions post the very same question 4 times and at the same time? Why do student's ask us to do their homework? Why do so many Askers not choose an answer and leave it up to the voters (well I really like the voters because they seem to read all of the answers). Why do those perusing the questions put a thumbs down and often to very good answers. I know I don't ask a lot of questions but I have been thinking a lot about these few things lately.

Hello MYRA C,
I recently asked a similar question.

The answers I received were understanding but ...
1. Too many childish people (not just kids) using the thumbs down on perfectly good answers apparently trying to influence the asker's response (I mean, what's the deal with a whole 10 points anyway? Is money involved and no one told me? :-) )
2. I have NO idea why some people post the same question numerous times unless they believe that at different times of the day there are different people using the forum. This doesn't explain the same question being posted back to back to back.
3. Those that ask a question often forget to check back to pick an answer, even when they have received some very good ones - or they have simply "moved on." This forgetfulness works to the advantage of "point gatherers."
4. Copying and pasting is absolutely okay IF it addresses the question and the answerer sites the source (many, if not most fail to do this). The goal is simply to provide the best response possible to the question. If it comes from another source, that's okay. The answerer did the work.
5. Students ask for help because (a) they are lazy and are taking a "short cut," or (b) they genuinely need some assistance. Personally, I view this as another form of research and maybe even being smart and showing ingenuity. I don't mind it.

In short - can't answer. Next question is how can Yahoo Q/A be improved?

(Added: See? The thumbs down proves the point. :-) )

Q & A might be improved by eliminating thumbs up and thumbs down because I don't think they influence the asker's decision or that of the voters either. Report It


Other Answers (6)




="shown">
  • Ashtol's Avatar by Ashtol
    Member since:
    July 29, 2007
    Total points:
    1577 (Level 3)

    ="network">
  • Add to My Contacts
  • Block User

  • Perception.

    lol, good point.

    some people just have no lives I guess! :P

    Well its an open forum here so you get the good and bad. AS for posting the same thing more than once I have no clue to me its ridiculous. And as for the thumbs down shallow people do it to make their own answer look better I guess.

    I do try to read all answers before I vote. However not picking a best answer to a question you asked for example.....what is a good way to fix my hair? And to leave it to voters to pick instead of deciding which one you liked yourself is silly.

    I have always picked my best answer myself even if it was only one answer...lol.

    I think they are just interested in making points.

    Right on.....or they use your answer at some other point.Like its there answer.

    I just don't know, but I think some people might think why do people come on here and complain? think about it...





    The consumer Foods information on foodaq.com is for informational purposes only and is not a substitute for medical advice or treatment for any medical conditions.
    The answer content post by the user, if contains the copyright content please contact us, we will immediately remove it.
    Copyright © 2007 FoodAQ - Terms of Use - Contact us - Privacy Policy

    Food's Q&A Resources