How long is a peanut butter pie good for?!
Answers: I'm making a peanut butter pie which also will have jelly on the top. He wants it for this Superbowl weekend, but I don't know when I should make it. Does anyone know how long it'd be fine to eat? I don't want to make it too soon and it end up tasting horrid by sunday. thanks in advance.
It should keep for about 3 to 4 days in the refrigerator. If you make it ahead of time I wouldn't add the jelly until the day your serving it.
Make it on Sunday morning so it tastes best on Sunday night (for Super Bowl). If you make it Saturday, don't add the jelly until Sunday.
I say a week.......2 weeks your pushin it...but ya as long as it tastes good then eat it, by all means!
3-4 days, but try and make it on the same day that your serving it