Can castor sugar be substituted for confectioners sugar?!


Question: want to make some icing for muffins but dont have any confectioners sugar. Can i substitute castor sugar?


Answers: want to make some icing for muffins but dont have any confectioners sugar. Can i substitute castor sugar?

Yes .. you can.

But you have to grind it to powder.. using dry blander or coffee grinder.. then sift it because u want a smooth icing for you muffin.

That what I'll do all the times.

Castor would be too coarse. However, you could try it out, it might make a unique icing.

Your best bet would be to grind it up more in a food processor or a blender.

Confectioners sugar has a little cornstarch added to it to keep it from clumping because it is so fine. Castor sugar on the other hand is pure sugar that is ground fine but not a fine as powdered sugar. It really would be best if you could find your food processor and grind granulated sugar. However, if this is not an option powdered sugar can be used but it may cause your product to become cloudy.


Sugar has become an ingredient so widely used in everyday cooking and eating that many people take it for granted. But sugar was once so costly that only the wealthy could afford this sweet luxury.

While sugar had been cultivated in Persia and Arabia in the 4th century B.C., it never made it to the western world until the 8 th century. This early sugar bore little resemblance to the fine snowy white grains we now commonly stir into our coffee cups. Instead it ranged from off-white to light brown in color and came in the form of large solid blocks that had to be chiseled to yield the sweet substance that was then ground finer with a mortar and pestle.

Using sugar is much more convenient today, and supplies are cheap, so there's no need to horde it. It's nice to know, however, that if you find a good sale on sugar, it can be stored for an indefinite period. Just keep it in a tightly sealed container in a cool dry place.

Sugar comes in so many different forms it might seem confusing. Here is a breakdown of the most common types of sugars and their uses:

White or Granulated Sugar is a highly refined cane or beet sugar. The most common and widely used form of sugar, it is also available in cube form.

Castor or Caster Sugar is white sugar with a superfine grain, which allows it to dissolve almost instantly. Caster sugar can be substituted for white sugar in a direct one to one ratio. Because it dissolves so quickly, Caster sugar is great for sweetening cold liquids and works especially well in meringues.

Coarse Sugars or Sugar Crystals have grains about 4 times the size of granulated sugar. Coarse sugars are often available in a rainbow of decorative colors in supermarkets and cake decorating supply shops. Save money, follow this and get directions for how to make your own decorative, colored sugars.

Brown Sugar is made from a mixture of white sugar and molasses and is generally available in light or dark varieties. The darker the sugar, the more intense the molasses flavor. You substitute brown sugar for white in equal measure, the only difference is that the brown sugar should be firmly packed in the measuring cup. Brown sugar has a tendency to harden with age or when it exposed to air for too long, so try to store in tightly sealed plastic. If you brown sugar has hardened, you can soften it by storing it in a plastic bag with a raw wedge of apple for 2-3 days - it will be as good as new.

Raw Sugar, while light brown in color, should not be confused with or substituted for brown sugar. Raw sugar is what's left after sugarcane has been processed and refined. Some people believe that raw sugar has superior nutritive qualities, although most of the raw sugar marketed in the US has been purified to such a degree it pretty much negates this theory. Popular types of raw sugar include Demerara Sugar from Guyana and Barbados Sugar, a moist, fine textured sugar. Turbinado Sugar is raw sugar that has been steam cleaned to remove contaminates, leaving a light molasses flavored, tan colored sugar.

Confectioner's Sugar or Powdered Sugar started life out as granulated sugar before it was crushed to a superfine powder which is then mixed with a small amount of corn starch to prevent clumping. Confectioner's sugar is most often used to make icings and candies. It's also useful to add a quick decorative touch with a light dusting of the snowy white powder on cakes and other desserts. Confectioner's sugar is known as Icing Sugar in the UK and Sucre Glace in France.

Castor or Caster Sugar is white sugar with a superfine grain, which allows it to dissolve almost instantly. Caster sugar can be substituted for white sugar in a direct one to one ratio. Because it dissolves so quickly, Caster sugar is great for sweetening cold liquids and works especially well in meringues.





The consumer Foods information on foodaq.com is for informational purposes only and is not a substitute for medical advice or treatment for any medical conditions.
The answer content post by the user, if contains the copyright content please contact us, we will immediately remove it.
Copyright © 2007 FoodAQ - Terms of Use - Contact us - Privacy Policy

Food's Q&A Resources