How many people have watched a cow, goat, chicken be killed to eat?!


Question: My kids (3 and 2) are going a relatives house (they have a farm) and this relative believes there is nothing wrong with letting the kids watch the cows become dinner. I've never seen it in person before but where my husband came from, he as a child would kill a chicken for lunch.

I guess I feel like it will hurt them or severely traumatize them in some way to see this happen to an animal. I really need ya'lls opinion. Please.


Answers: My kids (3 and 2) are going a relatives house (they have a farm) and this relative believes there is nothing wrong with letting the kids watch the cows become dinner. I've never seen it in person before but where my husband came from, he as a child would kill a chicken for lunch.

I guess I feel like it will hurt them or severely traumatize them in some way to see this happen to an animal. I really need ya'lls opinion. Please.

go with it.
we are so protected from the real world these days; we buy meat under clingfilm from a supermarket. that is wrong.
you have to have a link with where stuff really comes from.

i saw a bullfight when i was seven. it didn't damage me. i'm neither a screaming vegan nor a homicidal maniac. i'm glad i saw it for the first time when i was seven, you cope better.
if i'd seen it when i was twenty seven it might have damaged me...

A trip to any slaughterhouse or a killing operation of any size would create a great many more vegans and vegiitarians

If I want meat in my freezer, I go to my uncle's farm and do the deed and even butcher myself. That goes for Beef, Pork, and Poultry because I do not trust stores and it is superior to store bought meat.

I grew up doing this and I feel like I am normal. Just make sure they are O.K. with attending and do not force the issue on them if they are not.

i have seen a chicken and a buffalo be killed to eat

If the kill the animals in a humain way then it should be okay. But taking them to a slaughter house could be a bad thing. I have been hunting ever sense I was alittle girl and I was just tought that is was the nature of things

I have killed rabbits to eat and my daughter watched when she was 6.
3 & 2 is aweful young.
My other daughter and a friend killed a chicken when they were 10, but it was a rooster that was chasing and pecking them. I made them pluck it so I could cook it.
Ask them if they could just wait a couple more years.

All of the above and when I was a child at that. If you let your children know how you feel about it the children likely will mimic your views. It is good for the kids to know where their food comes from and it will not traumatize them at all. Frankly at the ages of 3 and 2 they aren't even likely to remember it.

I've never seen any mammal slaughtered for food, although I did have the opportunity a few times. I don't know if I can handle it, I'm a real animal lover and lately I have also been feeling a bit guilty about eating meat.

Then again, when I was 12, the first real fish I caught was a nice bass. My friend and I had no idea what to do with it. So, assuming that what we saw in the cartoons was ok, we took a club (actually, a piece of firewood) to it and smacked it in the head. As soon as we hit the thing, I started crying like crazy.

I think that taught me resepect for what I eat. To this day, I always eat what is on my plate. I think its a real sin to waste food.

We spent every summer on grandpa's farm and saw everything be slaughtered for eating. My grandma would kill a fresh chicken whenever she was cooking one, she would just go grab one, pick up, break it's neck and chop the head off and bring it inside all in one fell swoop. Didn't phase us.
But after seeing chickens lay the eggs I went off eggs for years and my brother too, actually 40 years later he still won't eat eggs.

ive seen it but after a whileu 4gebout it

I am an avid hunter and i don't beleave there is anything wrong with children seeing animals die as long a they are done in a humane manner and the children are taught to respect animals as they are how humans survive.





The consumer Foods information on foodaq.com is for informational purposes only and is not a substitute for medical advice or treatment for any medical conditions.
The answer content post by the user, if contains the copyright content please contact us, we will immediately remove it.
Copyright © 2007 FoodAQ - Terms of Use - Contact us - Privacy Policy

Food's Q&A Resources