Why isn't some "vegetarians" eat poultry and fish?!


Question: I heard somewhere they don't consider it real meat. Why not? Birds and fish sure as heck aren't vegetables.


Answers: I heard somewhere they don't consider it real meat. Why not? Birds and fish sure as heck aren't vegetables.

If you are referring to the flexi/exsft (sp?)/skully/fake trace/etc. trolls saying they are vegetarians while they eat meat... I'm sorry you have encountered any of these people. They get their kicks out of spreading falsified information about vegetarianism. Just ignore anything they have to say.

If you are referring to people in general thinking vegetarians can eat fish, keep this in mind: By definition, half of the population has below average intelligence. Every other person you meet is an idiot.

Vegetarians don't eat chicken or fish... ever. Anyone that thinks otherwise is confused.

::edit::
Another "gem" from Skully...

"However, this is changing. Now we use the word "flexitarian vegetarian" to define those whose diet is primarily 70-90% vegetarian and the rest plant based. We are just like the Japanese, Indians, Chinese, etc. vegetarians."

If 70-90% of your diet is vegetarian, and the rest is plant based (also vegetarian), then it is completely vegetarian. Your tripping on your own faulty logic at this point... maybe it's time for you to retire.

So-called flexitarians (note: there really is no such thing, they are just picky eaters) eat meat, and are not vegetarian.

You are not like the Japanese, etc. "vegetarians", because they were never vegetarians. While a percentage of these cultures are and were veg*ns, only the percentage that didn't eat meat can correctly be named vegetarian. It is a very simple concept and I'm sorry that you cannot grasp it.

Some vegetarians are doing it for health reasons and not because they are animal lovers.

You just cannot be vegetarian if you eat meat of any kind, they are kidding themsleves. Just better to say I don't eat red meat. Thats what my sister says.

I have to agree. Real vegetarians don't eat any type of meat from any living animal. It IS considered real meat. Some people like to just say they are vegetarians but don't know how much really goes into it. It's a way of life. NOT a diet!

im a vegetarian.
and i agree, if you eat meat & fish n stuff... your not a vegetarian.
that means your a pescitarian.
pescitarians usually only eat white meat, or only eat fish.

but as for me, i dont eat any meat at all.


http://vegetarian.about.com/od/glossary/...

A true vegetarian eat NO meat at all. However some over the years have started eating fish and chicken for health concerns, like iron deficiency. I think it has become a personal choice, however 7th Day Adventist do not eat meat of any kind. Hope this helps.

The ones in this forum that say that are only trying to mislead you. They have a dislike for the vegers here.

The word "vegetarian" was created by the vegetarian society. Before they created it in the mid 1800's, there was no such thing as a vegetarian. Certainly people had followed the diet, but it wasn't named as such until the vegetarian society did so. As creator of the word, they are the only one's allowed to define it. Here is the definition of vegetarian:

http://www.vegsoc.org/info/definitions.h...

Well, as a vegan, I've heard people brag "Oh I've been a vegan for three weeks now" while stuffing fish fillet in their mouth.... Some people just don't understand. Also with vegetarianism, you have to watch out. Producers disquise animal products with other words. Cellulite is fat, but some people don't know. So study different food vocab.

Well from a chef's perspective "meat" is red meat, the poultry and fish are different categories. But you can't be vegetarian and eat those things. I don't eat red meat (I eat chicken, turkey, and salmon), but I don't call myself vegetarian.

They are misinformed and continue to spread confusion/misinformation by referring to themselves as "vegetarians" or "a TYPE of Vegetarian"

I'm ready to be tarred and faux-feathered.
If I'm at the boss's cookout, and she says, "Here, have a burger." I can say
A: " No, thanks. I'm a pescetarian. What's a pescatarian, you ask? It's someone who eats seafood, but no other meat. I don't eat factory meats, because I think it is a form of animal abuse, and am weaning off of eggs and dairy for the same reason."

Or

B: "No, thanks. I'm a vegetarian."

Vegetarian is a word people recognize, even if they are fuzzy on the details. I don't describe myself as a vegetarian on this site, because definitions are posted hourly.
I don't want to always be on a soapbox, especially when I barely know people and I don't like discussing my ethics at every get-together. I usually try to find a way for it not to come up, like have my plate so full of salad that no one notices I didn't get the ribs.

NO vegetarian eats poultry or fish. It simply defies the definition of vegetarian. Some people have a weird concept of the word "meat," but you can take that right out of the equation. Birds and fish are animals and vegetarians don't eat animals.

Overheard today: "You may not think fish are the brightest of god's creatures, but calling them a vegetable just seems a little harsh..."

Because they aren't vegetarians but they say they are anyway. I'm not sure why.

Certainly poultry and fish are "meat" and ancient cultures that are predominantly vegetarian . . . Japan, China, Okinawan, India, hae for centuries included fish, seafood and poultry in their diet. It's just the way it is.

Only in the West is the distinction between "who" is vegetarian and who isn't so cast in concrete. Basically the rest of the world cares less. I certainly don't.

However, this is changing. Now we use the word "flexitarian vegetarian" to define those whose diet is primarily 70-90% vegetarian and the rest plant based. We are just like the Japanese, Indians, Chinese, etc. vegetarians. The word has been used since the 90's ... and if you Google "Flexitarian" or "flexitarian Diets" or "flexitarian vegetarians" you will get thousands and thousands of hits. Try it.

So it is a reality and we're here to stay. I will say, eating "red" meat is VERY, VERY rare among flexitarians. Mostly we stick with the "white" meats ... fish, poultry, seafood.

Thank you for asking....and YES ... birds and fish are NOT vegetables.





The consumer Foods information on foodaq.com is for informational purposes only and is not a substitute for medical advice or treatment for any medical conditions.
The answer content post by the user, if contains the copyright content please contact us, we will immediately remove it.
Copyright © 2007 FoodAQ - Terms of Use - Contact us - Privacy Policy

Food's Q&A Resources