Does the Dairy industry cause suffering?!


Question: Please don't post rude or nasty comments, I genuinely want to know why everyone thinks it's so cruel.

I don't know much about it.

What happens to the cows? etc etc
I just want your opinion.
Thanks!! h.h :-)

Answers: Please don't post rude or nasty comments, I genuinely want to know why everyone thinks it's so cruel.

I don't know much about it.

What happens to the cows? etc etc
I just want your opinion.
Thanks!! h.h :-)
Ethical impacts of intensive dairy farming:

Drinking milk does contruibute to unnessary death and suffering. Just like humans cows only lactate a few months after birth. For cows to produce a constant supply of milk they must be continually artificially ensiminated and give birth. Their babies are taken away from them soon after they are born. If they are male they will be trapped in veal crates, fed an anemic diet and confined in darkness and eventually killed. If they are female they will go on to also be dairy cows (or more correctly milk machines). This seperation causes distress to both mother and calf. Drinking milk supports the veal industry. Cows are also pumped with hormones and antibiotics to increase milk production. This often leads to mastitius, a painful infection of the udders. Constant milk production leaches calcium from cow's bones leaving them eventually lame or crippled.

If you really can't live without dairy try buying from certified free range dairy farmers. But everyone has to make their own decion in the end.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Sr-EyIaXA...
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=b7cGLywGS...
.........................................

Environmental impacts of intensive dairy farming:

A single cow produces approximately 120 pounds of manure per day, in other words the amount of waste proced by 1 cow = 20-40 humans. That means each farm produces thousand of litres of waste effluent into environment. It pollutes our soil, water tables and streams. Cows also produce a lot of gasses, especially methane. Methane is 4 times more potent and CO2 in terms of green house emission. Cows are treated like milk machines to increase productivity. Environmentally speaking cows are also very inefficient at converting foodstuffs into milk. Only a small percentage of the food goes towards milk production. Most of the energy goes towards metabolic activity and simply staying alive. The dairy industry is also a huge burden on water resources.

.........................................
[edit]: JAM you may work or be familiar with smaller scale dairy farms. Most milk is produced in large scale intensive farming facilities, they process not hundreds but thousands of cows. And it is simply physically impossible to “love each and every one of their cows”. They are milked and fed by automatic machines… where’s the love? Not nonsense it's the truth. I'm not ignorant I know there are two sides to the story. But the overwhelming majority of dairy is produced in intensive farming facilities. Maybe you should consider doing some research, before you call my answer nonsense.
Naive and stupid! Report It

Other Answers (13)

="shown">
  • Biw's Avatar by Biw
    Member since:
    November 21, 2007
    Total points:
    578 (Level 2)
    ="network">
  • Add to My Contacts
  • Block User
    • Unfortunatley they do. You can find info on that at Petas website and other places like that. They do get killed in front of each other to the one above me. Get some education before giving people advice on things you dont even know about.
    Absolutely. The cows do not lead normal lives, they are forceably impregnated and their calves are taken away. They suffer horribly, and the male calves are turned into veal. Please check the links I'm posting for more info.
    yer it can do the babies are normally taken form the mums at a young age, and theyre basically all treated like ****/items of our disposal, thats why some go vegan (im vegeterian)
    www.milksucks.com

    here is what you're looking for dude!
    watch this video: meat.com
    its really sad.

    if you drink milk, you are supporting the veal industry.
    Of course it does.

    Milk production wains after a few years and then the cows are used for cheap ground beef.

    When males are born, they are used in the super-cruel veal industry.

    All calves are torn from their mothers after virtually no time at all.
    Cow's milk is meant for calf.But cow as well of calf is fed and protected by humans.So man takes part of the milk (to be used by calf ) There is nothing immoral about it.
    "I think I'll tell my parents to buy more soya milk!!"

    Are you old enough to buy your own soya milk?
    Yes dairy cows suffer. They are milked until they are spent, then they are slaughtered. A dairy cow will live approximately 25% of her natural life before being made into hamburgers.

    JAM: You're a smart girl. I know you're not foolish enough to believe that every dairy farm in the civilized world is exactly the same as the one your father operates. And I know you're not naive enough to believe that the world will become overpopulated with cows should animal-exploitation industries suddenly cease to exist.

    As for your question of what to do with all the cows and steers should the animal-agri industry suddelny cease, I propose reparations. For example, since your father facilitated the slavery of these creatures to build his own assets, he should in return offer a portion of his assets to the liberates cows and steer in the currency of land that they might live on. Seems only fair.

    The reality is that no matter how "happy" and "cooperative" you believe the slaves are, they're still slaves. And I don't care what species you are - you don't deserve to be anyone's slave.
    Yes. It causes lots of suffering. The cows are treated poorly. They are constantly re-inseminated only to have their babies taken away at birth. The female babies go on to follow in her mothers unfortunate foot steps, and the male babies go off to veal farms where they are kept in tiny crates just waiting for death. Check out www.peta.org for more info.
    They get their little cow booobies squeezed.

    Why do vegans think it's okay to KILL plants?

    How do you know plants don't feel pain?

    *Evil laugh*
    They get killed in a very nice way imaginable by human

    Not in fron tof other cows

    If livestock are killed violently etc i think there is a law thing on it..

    not sure though

    oh w8 r u talkin about cows being milked?

    well nz lives on that so i think it should't be 2 bad...

    -_-
    Hold it - hold it! Before you lot start dairy bashing - have any of you actually been to a dairy farm or an abatoir? It certainly sounds like you haven't since you are quoting propaganda sites like Peta. The UK, Canada and the USA have the most incredible farming systems of any in the world. Generally farmers love each and every one of their cows, not just because they provide their living but because they have to love them to find the strength to get up at four every morning! Cows wether beef or dairy are treated exceptionally well and if everyone stops eating meet or drinking milk what will happen to all the cows? No one will keep them just for fun so infact your more likely to cause the dimise of several million cows simply beacuse you don't like that they are impregnated by artificial insemination and not by horny little bull attacking anything in the way!

    I simply wish that rather than "educating" yourselves and others with websites that tell only half a story through very twisted eyes, that you actually visit a farm and see what happens and then having seen what great lives cows really lead make an informed choice as to wether to drink milk or eat beef...

    Please people open to eyes properly and see the real world - its not at a computer its down a country lane!

    HALA - you're talking nonsense- cows will milk of their own accord for sometimes years- much like humans! Further more I have sheds and shed and fields of calves that are not in veal crates and never will be! Hardly any calves are sent for veal, please be correctly informed - go talk to a farmer... not a computer!

    VEGGIE W: Thank you youre right I am a smart girl! But whilst I understand not all dairy farms are perfect - I think you would be surprised at how nice dairy farms really are...
    Further more the world will not become overpopulated should everyone cease eating meat, but quite the opposite, no industry= no requirement, what should we do turf cows wild on to the street or kill and burn them since they have no further use to the world... ever thought about that?


    The consumer Foods information on foodaq.com is for informational purposes only and is not a substitute for medical advice or treatment for any medical conditions.
    The answer content post by the user, if contains the copyright content please contact us, we will immediately remove it.
    Copyright © 2007 FoodAQ - Terms of Use - Contact us - Privacy Policy

    Food's Q&A Resources